Criminal investigation

Lawful Silence, Unlawful Assumptions: Bail, Confession, and Constitutional Rights

Summary: The police are legally obligated to conduct investigations and gather evidence through lawful means. Under Article 20(3) of the Constitution, an accused person cannot be compelled to confess, as the right against self-incrimination is a protected fundamental right. Therefore, choosing not to make self-incriminating statements or confessions cannot be construed as “non-cooperation” during a police investigation. Such refusal, being constitutionally valid, cannot be used by the police as grounds to oppose bail or anticipatory bail applications.Continue Reading Lawful Silence, Unlawful Assumptions: Bail, Confession, and Constitutional Rights

Nascent stage of investigation no bar for quashing: Supreme Court clarifies High Court’s power under Section 528 BNSS

Summary: The power to quash a criminal matter under Section 528 BNSS, 2023 (erstwhile Section 482, CrPC, 1973), is well settled. It is a power to be exercised sparingly, within well accepted parameters, including no offence being disclosed, malice, abuse of criminal process, etc. If such relevant factors otherwise stand fulfilled, there is no bar to quashing an FIR, even if the investigation is at a preliminary/ nascent stage.Continue Reading Nascent stage of investigation no bar for quashing: Supreme Court clarifies High Court’s power under Section 528 BNSS

When Further Investigation Under Section 173(8) CRPC is Impermissible

OVERVIEW

A criminal trial is nearing its conclusion. The evidence has been led, and witnesses examined and cross examined. Only the final arguments remain. Yet, for “the pursuit of truth”, would a “further investigation” be permissible at such a belated stage? In several judgments, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has answered this question in the affirmative, subject to there being compelling facts justifying such an extraordinary measure.Continue Reading When Further Investigation Under Section 173(8) CRPC is Impermissible