Dispute Resolution

Accused’s Right to Access Not Relied Upon Documents: Supreme Court Clarifies Scope and Timing of Production

Summary – In CBI v. Anil Dixit, the Supreme Court clarified the distinction between inspection and production of documents collected during investigation but not relied upon by the prosecution. The accused may inspect such material and seek production of specific records at the appropriate trial stage, or identify them through a jointly signed list for prompt production before the Trial Court. Investigating agencies cannot be compelled to produce documents they do not possess; the accused may obtain these independently, with their evidentiary value determined by the Trial Court. the ruling is significant as its document-specific approach balances access to potentially relevant defence material with the expeditious conduct of criminal trials.

Continue Reading Accused’s Right to Access Not Relied Upon Documents: Supreme Court Clarifies Scope and Timing of Production
Supreme Court: Arbitral Tribunals Cannot Rewrite Contracts

Summary: In Shreeram Builders v. Upendra Kantilal Thanawala, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 2294, the Supreme Court held that an arbitral tribunal cannot replace express contractual terms with new obligations while granting relief. This judgement raises a critical question: when does an award enforce the parties’ contract, and when does the relief granted impermissibly rewrite it?

Continue Reading Supreme Court: Arbitral Tribunals Cannot Rewrite Contracts

      

Summary: Managing directors, directors and senior officers are often at the receiving end of corporate criminal proceedings without allegations of personal involvement merely because of their positions. This overlooks a settled principle, viz., that criminal law does not recognise vicarious liability unless expressly provided by statute.

Continue Reading Guilt by Designation? Revisiting Vicarious Liability in Criminal Law
The silent shift: Beneficial ownership and the untested edge of pledge-related contra trades

Summary: Creation, invocation and revocation of a pledge of shares fall within the meaning of “trade” under the PIT Regulations, and the FAQs on the PIT Regulations are unambiguous on this point. These pledge-related transactions trigger contra trade restriction under Schedule B of the PIT Regulations. SEBI’s informal guidance clarifies how the regulatory position on this subject has evolved. This article traces this evolution and analyses the considerations relevant to listed entities when creating pledges.

Continue Reading The silent shift: Beneficial ownership and the untested edge of pledge-related contra trades
“Bar To Sue” Under Order II Rule 2 Versus “Suit Barred By Law” Under Order VII Rule 11: Crucial Procedural Distinction

Summary: A plea under Order II Rule 2 may defeat a plaintiff’s claim or relief arising from the same cause of action. However, the Supreme Court recently clarified in S. Valliammai v. S. Ramanathan that such a plea alone is not sufficient to reject the suit under Order VII Rule 11(d). The key is understanding the difference between a “bar to sue” and a “suit barred by law”. This article explores that distinction, the different inquiries mandated under each provision, and the significant procedural consequences of invoking the wrong remedy at the threshold stage.

Continue Reading “Bar To Sue” Under Order II Rule 2 Versus “Suit Barred By Law” Under Order VII Rule 11: Crucial Procedural Distinction

Summary: As businesses become increasingly global, requests from foreign regulators, courts and law-enforcement agencies for information held in India are becoming a routine part of cross-border compliance. Businesses must now play the balancing act—comply with India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (“DPDP Act”), and the Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025 (“DPDP Rules”), on the one hand, and the laws of the requesting jurisdiction on the other. The DPDP framework does not automatically exempt foreign regulatory requests. Business must, therefore, regularly assess the basis for processing and disclosure, cross-border transfer requirements and, determine whether such request should be routed through an Indian legal mechanism.

Continue Reading Foreign Regulatory Requests: Balancing Cooperation, Compliance and Data Protection

Summary: This article aims to analyse the Draft Reserve Bank of India (Know Your Customer) Amendment Directions, 2026 in light of the current legislative and judicial framework and practical challenges faced by entities and individuals upon debit-freezing of accounts in relation to financial crimes and cyber frauds.

Continue Reading Towards Certainty: RBI’s Draft Directions on Debit Freeze
No Shield For Directors? BHC Analyses The Applicability Of The Moratorium Under Sections 96 And 101 Of The IBC To Prosecutions Under Section 138 Of The NI Act

Summary: This blog analyses a recent BHC judgment that delineates the contours of the interim moratorium under Section 96 of the IBC vis-à-vis the initiation/ continuation of a prosecution under Sections 138 read with 141 of the NI Act against the directors of a company.

Continue Reading No Shield For Directors? BHC Analyses The Applicability Of The Moratorium Under Sections 96 And 101 Of The IBC To Prosecutions Under Section 138 Of The NI Act
Contours of Interim Moratorium under Section 96 of IBC, 2016

Summary: This blog delineates the contours of interim moratorium under Section 96 of the IBC. It explores the provision’s interaction with the SARFAESI Act, 2002, its application to co-owned properties, the 2026 amendment to Section 96, and potential future legislative changes.

Continue Reading Contours of Interim Moratorium under Section 96 of IBC, 2016
Beyond Trading: The Evolving Law on UPSI Communication

Summary: An allegation of communication of unpublished price sensitive information under Regulation 3 of the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015, cannot be established merely basis proximity between parties or trading pattern. Balram Garg held that cogent material such as emails, letters, etc., will be required. The recent AGEL and RHI Magnesita orders sharpen this further, showing that a call or contact between parties, without more, will not suffice. Ultimately, the outcome of any allegation of UPSI communication is fact sensitive. Together, these rulings establish a clear evidentiary requirement: that SEBI must prove that UPSI was communicated, not merely that the parties had the opportunity to communicate it.

Continue Reading Beyond Trading: The Evolving Law on UPSI Communication