Foreign Arbitral Award

Summary: The Bombay High Court, in Osterreichischer Lloyd v. Victore Ships, has held that a party seeking to enforce a foreign arbitral award in India does not lose its right to seek interim protective relief under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, merely by filing a petition for recognition and enforcement under Part II. Such relief remains available at least until the award is recognised as an enforceable decree under Section 49. This ruling strengthens the hand of award-creditors seeking to prevent dissipation of assets while enforcement is pending. It also reaffirms India’s pro-enforcement stance towards foreign awards. However, the judgement leaves open the more difficult question of whether Section 9 relief continues to be available even after the award is recognised as a decree, during the execution stage. High Courts remain divided on it and may require clarification from the Supreme Court.

Continue Reading Section 9 and Foreign Award Enforcement: Jurisdictional Question Settled, but Boundaries Still Uncertain
Bombay High Court Closes the Door on Enforcing Foreign Awards Against Non-Parties

Summary: This article analyses the Bombay High Court’s decision in Ningbo Aux Imp and Exp Co Ltd v. Amstrad Consumer India Pvt Ltd & Anr., which held that enforcement of a foreign arbitral award under Part II of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, is confined to persons between whom the award was made, and directed deletion of a non-party guarantor from enforcement proceedings. The article also examines the subsequent Section 9 petition, dismissed on the ground that interim measures cannot be directed against a party against whom the award is not enforceable.

Continue Reading Bombay High Court Closes the Door on Enforcing Foreign Awards Against Non-Parties
The “all or nothing” problem: Partial Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards

Summary: When a foreign arbitral award hits a snag, should the entire award sink or can the enforceable part still sail through? Indian law is clear on severability for domestic awards, but foreign awards remain in a grey zone. While global practice leans toward partial enforcement to protect legitimate claims, India risks being an outlier. It’s time for a pragmatic shift that aligns with international norms and safeguards commercial certainty.

Continue Reading The “all or nothing” problem: Partial Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards